Skip to main content
REASON TO LOVE RENTER
rr_badge
  • Real reviews from real people
  • Compare reviews by city
  • Easy to read ratings, plus a specific breakdown
  • Assurance of reliability and quality
  • Increase information and confidence
  • Read review comments from renters
  • Increase information and confidence

Andy's Rent A Car Renter Rated Reviews - Page 10

The inside front window was really dirty and hard to see out of. We usually pick up at the airport and found the (3) hours per day only on weekdays to not be as convenient as the main office. However, we always rent from Andy's and they have been great.
Mon Oct 12, 2026 - Bill and Pat

We love Andy’s and have been renting from them for over 20 years! Great value and service!
Mon Oct 12, 2026 - Renter Review

Agents could have been friendlier , no smiles no welcomes, I rent every year when I come down and have noticed this each time. Good value for the Money.
Mon Oct 12, 2026 - Renter Review

Very polite and patient staff who understand travelers have recently arrived to the island and may be fatigued. Observed staff to defuse a customer quickly that was being rude and unwilling to accept his error in fuel.
Mon Oct 12, 2026 - Renter Review

Just all good
Mon Oct 12, 2026 - Renter Review

Just all good
Mon Oct 12, 2026 - Renter Review

Just all good
Mon Oct 12, 2026 - Renter Review

Very enjoyable car rental experience.
Sun Oct 11, 2026 - Renter Review

Car was very poor condition
Sun Oct 11, 2026 - Renter Review

I rent with Andy's about every two months. It would be great if they could retain all my customer information in their system so I didn't have to go through the document signing process each time. Similar to the Hertz Gold process I enjoy in the U.S. Also, lately they only have one staff member working and they have to do everything. There really should be two staff members working the counter all the time to handle new rentals and returns.
Fri Oct 9, 2026 - Renter Review